Superfund Information Systems: Site Profile

Superfund Site:

ONONDAGA LAKE
SYRACUSE, NY

Cleanup Activities

On this page:

On related pages:


Background

Onondaga Lake is located along the northern side of the City of Syracuse in Onondaga County, New York. The lake itself covers an area of 4.6 square miles. Its shoreline borders the city of Syracuse, as well as the towns of Geddes and Salina and villages of Solvay and Liverpool. The site includes the lake and seven major and other minor tributaries and upland sources of contamination. The lake receives water from a drainage basin of approximately 285 square miles, located almost entirely within Onondaga County. Effluent from the Metropolitan Syracuse Wastewater Treatment Plant discharges into the southeastern end of the lake. The lake flows into the Seneca River, which flows into the Oswego River. The Oswego River ultimately flows into Lake Ontario.

Onondaga Lake has been the recipient of industrial and municipal sewage discharges for more than 100 years. The availability of salt and limestone along and in the vicinity of Onondaga Lake led Honeywell International, Inc.’s (Honeywell’s) predecessor companies (e.g., Solvay Process Company, Allied Chemical Corp. and AlliedSignal, Inc.) to locate along the west side of the lake. In 1946, Allied Chemical started a mercury cell process that resulted in waste streams containing mercury and heavy metals being discharged by its facilities at Willis Avenue and Bridge Street. Honeywell’s Semet Residue Ponds are another source of contamination to the lake. While Honeywell is the site’s primary potentially responsible party (PRP), other industrial and manufacturing facilities located along the shore or tributaries to the lake are sources of contamination to the lake. Site investigations and cleanup activities are ongoing. The EPA and New York State have determined that the site poses no immediate threat to human health or the environment while studies are underway.

The EPA placed the site on the Superfund program’s National Priorities List in December 1994.

The control of contamination migrating to Onondaga Lake from the various upland sites is an integral part of the overall cleanup of the lake. To facilitate coordination of the various investigations and remedial activities at the lake and the upland sources, the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation and the EPA have, to date, identified 12 subsites which are part of the Onondaga Lake site:  Lake Bottom; General Motors - Inland Fisher Guide; Geddes Brook/Ninemile Creek; LCP Bridge Street; Ley Creek PCB Dredgings; Lower Ley Creek; National Grid - Hiawatha Boulevard; Semet Tar Beds; Town of Salina Landfill; Wastebeds 1-8; Wastebed B/Harbor Brook, and Willis Avenue. New York State is the lead agency for all of the subsites except for Lower Ley Creek.

Top of Page


What Has Been Done to Clean Up the Site?

Interim Remedial Measures (IRMs): IRMs undertaken at the site include removing chlorobenzene from existing wells; altering existing on-site sewers; on-site demolition, removal, decontamination and recycling of former mercury cell processing buildings and building materials; cleaning storm drainage systems; investigation of berms surrounding the Semet Tar Ponds; design and construction of a lakeshore barrier wall and groundwater collection/treatment system; and removal of some contaminated sediments and floodplain soils in or adjacent to Geddes Brook and Ninemile Creek.

Long-term Cleanup: Investigations and long-term remedial actions at the various subsites are being performed by the site’s PRPs, pursuant to enforcement agreements between the PRPs and the State of New York. EPA has contributed over $16.5 million to the State of New York for various activities at the site, including investigations, coordination and management at subsites, implementation of a citizen involvement plan, creation of a site-wide database, and establishment of a comprehensive
enforcement program.

Dredging in Onondaga Lake was performed from 2012 through 2014, removing approximately 2.2 million cubic yards of contaminated material. Isolation and thin-layer capping of contaminated lake sediment, which began in 2012, was completed in 2016.

Top of Page


What Is the Current Site Status?

Cleanup activities at the subsites have been or are being performed via various means (e.g., as part of a cleanup remedy selected in a Record of Decision or as an interim remedial measure). With the exception of the Lower Ley Creek subsite, where the investigation was performed under federal authorities, the investigations and cleanup actions at the other subsites have been or are being performed by the subsites’ potentially responsible parties (PRPs), pursuant to enforcement agreements between the PRPs and the State of New York.

Between 1998 and September 2018, cleanup remedies were selected for 11 of the subsites. Selected cleanup remedies include dredging of contaminated sediments, excavation of contaminated soils, in-situ, on- and off-site treatment of contaminated materials, collection and treatment of contaminated groundwater, and capping of contaminated soils and sediments. New York State is the lead agency for all of the subsites except for Lower Ley Creek. More information about the status of the cleanup of the subsites and the lake bottom can be found on the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation’s (NYSDEC's) Region 7 Project Information webpage.

The status of the Lake Bottom subsite and the federal-lead Lower Ley Creek subsite are discussed below. Dredging of contaminated lake sediments (Lake Bottom subsite) began in summer 2012 and was completed in November 2014. Approximately 2.2 million cubic yards of contaminated sediment was removed from the lake bottom and three shoreline areas. The dredging and related capping and habitat restoration work were performed by Honeywell International with oversight by the NYSDEC, the EPA, and the New York State Department of Health. Capping, which included the placement of more than 3 million cubic yards of material consisting primarily of sand, activated carbon, siderite, and stone, was completed in December 2016.  Habitat restoration activities, including improving wetlands and planting native plants, shrubs, and trees in shoreline areas, were completed in late 2017.

NYSDEC and EPA issued a Record of Decision (ROD) in 2002 for the Semet Residue Ponds Subsite.  The selected remedy addressed the contaminated material present in the ponds and the groundwater. The groundwater portion of the remedy was completed in 2013. A key element of the selected remedy was the reuse of the Semet residue. Specifically, the Semet residue was to be excavated, dewatered and then thermally processed on-site to produce a soft tar product (RT-12) that would be further processed off-site to make a driveway sealer.

Subsequent to the issuance of the ROD, changes in market conditions made it no longer feasible to produce RT-12 from the Semet residue. In addition, supplemental investigations revealed that there was much less Semet residue present in the ponds than was previously assumed. Because of the changed market conditions and based on the new residue quantity estimates, studies to identify and evaluate alternative approaches were undertaken. A Focused Feasibility Study was prepared to evaluate off-site thermal processing/reuse of the Semet residue. These documents demonstrated that off-site thermal processing is the best means to address the Semet residue. This change to the remedy was documented in a July 2017 Explanation of Significant Differences.

The cleanup of the LCP Bridge Street Subsite, one of two primary sources of mercury entering the lake, was completed in 2015.

Remedial activities for the Geddes Brook/Ninemile Creek Subsite, which was impacted by sources at the LCP Bridge Street Subsite, were completed in 2014.

Along the southern shore of the lake, a steel barrier wall and groundwater extraction system have been constructed and are in operation so as to prevent contaminated groundwater from entering the lake from the Semet Residue Ponds, Willis Avenue, and Wastebed B/Harbor Brook Subsites. Approximately 75,000 gallons of free product chlorinated benzenes have been removed, to date, from subsurface soils at the Willis Avenue Subsite using recovery wells and sent off-site for treatment/disposal.

An interim remedial measure to address contaminated groundwater migration and seeps at, and mitigate erosion of Solvay waste along the shoreline of, the Wastebeds 1-8 Subsite commenced in 2013. A ROD for operable unit (OU) 1 of the Wastebeds 1-8 Subsite, which includes Solvay waste and contaminated soil/fill materials present, was issued in 2014. The remedy consists of a two-foot thick soil cover over areas where active recreation is planned or where appropriate to protect ecological resources, and a one-foot thick soil cover where passive recreation is planned.  The remedy has been completed in the area of the site where Onondaga County’s Lakeview Amphitheater and related facilities were constructed.

NYSDEC and EPA selected a remedy for the Wastebed B/Harbor Brook Subsute in September 2018. The remedy includes the installation of a cover system that would be protective for current and/or reasonably anticipated future land uses (e.g., active and passive recreational uses); vegetation enhancement; and wetland construction/restoration with a low permeability cover. The remedy also includes the performance of a Preliminary Design Investigation and dense non-aqueous phase liquid (DNAPL) evaluation, following which, recovery would be performed on a portion of the Subsite (if recoverable DNAPL is identified). This area would also receive installation of a soil/granular or asphalt cover and other actions (e.g., removal, stabilization), if necessary, to provide long-term isolation of underlying impacted soils.

The General Motors (GM) Inland Fisher Guide (IFG) Subsite includes two operable units. OU1 of this subsite is the former GM-IFG Syracuse Plant property that is located south of Ley Creek on Town Line Road in the Town of Salina.  OU2 includes Ley Creek channel sediments, surface water, and floodplain soils/sediments in the reach from Townline Road to the Route 11 Bridge.

A remedial investigation/feasibility study (RI/FS) is ongoing for OU1. An RI report was approved in 2017. A revised FS report, which evaluates remedial alternatives to address the contamination at OU1, is under review. A ROD is anticipated in late 2019.  

A cleanup remedy for OU2 was selected by NYSDEC and EPA in 2015. The remedy includes excavating approximately 25,000 cubic yards of PCB-contaminated sediment and soil. The contractor is performing the work in two parts--the wetland and Factory Ave. soil areas and the Ley Creek and floodplain hotspot areas. Excavation to remove PCB-contaminated soil from residential properties adjacent to Upper Ley Creek was conducted in 2016.  

The wetland and Factory Ave soil remediation has been completed. A draft construction completion report is expected in early 2019.

Comments on an interim remedial design plan to address PCB-contaminated sediments and soil in the creek/floodplain were provided to the contractor in December 2017. The final design plan is anticipated shortly.

 

Remediation at the Ley Creek PCB Dredgings Subsite was completed in 2000. The site is undergoing long-term maintenance and monitoring.

Construction activities at the Salina Landfill Subsite began in 2011. Waste consolidation from the landfill area south of Ley Creek to the landfill area on the northern side of Ley Creek was completed in 2011. Construction of the 50-acre landfill capping system and of the groundwater-collection trench north of Ley Creek was completed in the fall 2013. Construction and startup of the on-site leachate treatment system was completed in early 2015.

A ROD for the Niagara-Mohawk Hiawatha Boulevard Subsite was issued in 2010. The remedial design of the selected remedy for soil was completed in 2011. The selected remedy calls for contaminated soil in the northeastern portion of the Subsite that could leach contaminants to groundwater to be solidified in place and groundwater along the northern perimeter of the Subsite to be treated using enhanced bioremediation. The in-situ soil solidification portion of the remedy was completed in May 2014. A pilot study for enhanced bioremediation of groundwater was completed.  Construction of the groundwater component of the remedy is expected to be completed in 2019.

In 2014, the EPA finalized its plan to clean up contaminated soil and sediment at the Lower Ley Creek subsite, located in the city of Syracuse and town of Salina. The cleanup will include excavation and capping of contaminated soil and sediment in Lower Ley Creek and disposal of the excavated soil and sediment. The parties potentially responsible for contamination at the site are currently working on the remedial design in accordance with an Administrative Order on Consent with EPA.

Feasibility studies are currently underway for the Willis Avenue and Waste Beds 1-8 (groundwater) Subsites and for areas of the Wastebed B Site/Harbor Brook and Semet Tar Beds Subsites not addressed by the RODs noted above.  It is anticipated that the feasibility studies and Proposed Plans for the Willis Avenue and Semet Tar Beds Subsites will be released to the public in fall 2018 and that remedies will be selected in winter 2019. 

 

Top of Page